Grow Your World

Thursday, February 16, 2006

Moscow, Russia -- January 2006

February 12, 2006

It was a bone chilling -25 degrees in Moscow as I greeted 250 Jewish university students representing the 27 Hillel Jewish student centers in Russia, Ukraine, Moldova, Belarus, Uzbekistan, Azerbaijan, and Georgia at the 7th annual Hillel in the Former Soviet Union (FSU) Winter Congress. Within minutes the frozen Russian winter was left behind as old friends embraced and new friends met one another.

The Hillel in the FSU Winter Congress brings together young Jewish leaders from throughout the far flung Jewish communities of the FSU to participate in Jewish education workshops and seminars and to socialize and network with one another. There are more than 1 million Jews remaining in the former Soviet Union and Hillel reaches approximately 10,000 students per year.

It was impossible for me to take part in the Hillel in the FSU Winter Congress and not to marvel at the fact that these Jews are able to both congregate and celebrate their Judaism in Russia today. When their parents were students they never could have met openly as Jews and never had the opportunity to explore their Judaism or to connect to the Jewish people.

As always, history has a short memory. When I asked these mostly 18-22 year olds if they feel lucky to have this opportunity to connect to the Jewish community, they did not even understand the question. Like their peers in North America and Israel, these students take their freedom and ability to practice Judaism for granted. To them, the end of Communism, a mere fifteen years ago, is ancient history.

Aside from the support for the creation and sustenance of the State of Israel, the advocacy movement in the USA in the 1970s and 1980s to aid and free Soviet Jewry was the most important accomplishment by the American Jewish community in the 20th century. Through lobbying efforts and community organizing, the American Jewish community was able to influence and pressure those in power both in Washington and, more importantly, behind the Iron Curtain. From the Marches in Washington to the twinnings at Bar and Bat Mitzvahs, the Soviet Jewry movement was an extraordinary demonstration of the strength of the American Jewish community and of the power of civil society to effect change on a global level.

As I sat and talked with the students in Moscow, I badly wanted to explain to them how lucky they are to have the opportunity to attend this conference. I couldn’t help but wonder if Hillel conferences will be possible in the FSU in another ten or fifteen year. A number of recent developments make me wary: Russia has just passed a series of laws restricting the operation of foreign operated non-profit organizations; the “Orange Revolution” in Ukraine is faltering and President Yuscheknko will likely be defeated this year, Belarus’ dictator Alexander Lukashenko is arranging his own reelection, and Uzbekistan’s Islam Karimov continues to repress minorities. An alarming recent study called “Failing the Stalin Test” published in Foreign Affairs analyzed the findings of surveys taken by young people in Russia this year:
The single most remarkable finding of these two surveys is that less than half of Russia's young people would categorically reject voting for Stalin today. Even if younger Russians are less likely to support him than are older ones, the majority of Russia's youth appear to harbor ambivalent or positive feelings toward one of the worst dictators in world history.
Today’s former Soviet Republics are confusing places for young people to grow up. Their societies suffer from post-Soviet hangovers characterized by a large number of disaffected and alienated elderly, a tiny minority of mega-rich among a large number of very poor people, almost no trust in public institutions, a declining birth rate and embarrassingly low mortality rates (In Russia, life expectancy for men is approximately 61.) At the same time, their economies are growing and they have access to western goods and information. Most of the students I speak with do not plan on emigrating. They see their future in the FSU. But what kind of former Soviet republics will they inherit?

To ensure a future of freedom in the FSU, it is vital that the governments of Russia, Ukraine and the other republics create and be pressured to enact policies that foster open, democratic societies. Concurrently, it is crucial that grassroots, civil societies be cultivated and strengthened.

Religious organizations such as Hillel play a vital role in creating Jewish community for thousands of Jews and also in strengthening civil society. Hillel’s mission is to build Jewish community by providing the maximum number of Jewish young adults with opportunities to explore Judaism in a pluralistic environment. Hillel is also training a generation of Jewish students who will be empowered to lead their communities in the next few decades. One new Hillel project is a social justice program that will provide students with skills in community planning and welfare provision along with structured volunteer opportunities.

Over four days in Moscow, I watched the Jewish students soak up Jewish knowledge and strengthen their Jewish identities. There were workshops on career development, Jewish perspectives on dating and sex, Jewish holidays, Shabbat, and opportunities for experiences in Israel. Though the future of freedom in the FSU remains uncertain, we must seize the opportunity help these young Jews connect to the Jewish people and build strong, sustainable communities.

Saturday, November 19, 2005

Khabarovsk, Russia

Two weeks ago, I flew first almost 5,000 miles to Moscow and then another 3,000 miles and seven time zones from Moscow to the city of Khabarovsk in Russia’s Far East. I went to visit the staff and students of Khabarovsk Hillel. Hillel is the primary organization that serves Jewish students at most universities in North America. But yes, there is a Hillel in Khabarovsk, Russia.

In fact, Hillel has operated in the former Soviet Union for more than 10 years and has opened 27 student centers in seven former Soviet republics. Although more than 1.5 million Jews left the region after the Soviet Union collapsed, more than 1 million Jews remain. Out of an estimated global Jewish population of only about 14 million, the remaining Jews of the former Soviet Union remain a significant component of World Jewry.

Khabarovsk sits on the Amur River, which is Russia’s largest source of salmon and caviar and also serves as the Russian Chinese border. The first thing I saw upon landing at the Khabarovsk airport through the grey fog and falling snow was a large statue of Lenin and a crumbling Soviet hammer and sickle. Next, I was greeted by the 21 year old Hillel Director, Ilya Baru. Ilya drove me into the center of Khabarovsk which has a population of approximately 600,000. The day of my arrival coincided with a major holiday in Soviet times, the anniversary of the 1917 Soviet Revolution,. The holiday was cancelled under Yeltsin and replaced by a November 4 celebration called Russian Unity Day by Putin.

When we arrived at Khabarovsk’s main square, 50-60 mostly older people in heavy coats and fur hats were gathered under a Great Patriotic War (World War II) statue waving Soviet flags and holding up placards bearing the likenesses of Lenin and Stalin. A rag-tag band played old Soviet hymns and many of them danced together in the falling snow. Their normally bitter and downcast faces glowed as they re-lived what they think of as the glory days of the Soviet Union.

Today’s Russia is a country of stark contrasts. The nouveaux riche and growing middle class of Moscow eats Sushi, goes to Yoga classes, and drives SUVs to the Moscow IKEA to buy the latest in do-it-yourself Swedish furniture. But most Russians remain poor and down-trodden with little reason to expect that their lives will improve.

Even within Khabarovsk I saw major contrasts. I had lunch with Ilya and his twin brother Igor at a trendy café called Chocolate where many Hillel students hang out. The café was located directly across the main square from where the old Communist gathering was still taking place. Ilya and Igor explained that most of the Jewish young adult population does not plan on leaving the area. They painted a picture of Khabarovsk as a city of pioneers with a thriving entrepreneurial spirit. They stressed that if you have the energy and the skills, Khabarovsk is a place you can succeed.

Khabarovsk is important for Russia for economic and geopolitical reasons. The two population centers of Russia’s Far-East are Khabarovsk and Vladivostok. Vladovistok is the major port city of the region and Khabarovsk is the primary educational center and indsutrial city with significant lumber, metal, and fishing industries.

Geopolitically, Khabarovsk is important because Russia is facing a major threat from neighboring China. Russia is undergoing a trend of de-population. With the average Russian man’s life-expectancy at 59 (lower than most sub-Saharan African countries) and families averaging only 1.7 children, the population is in significant decline. The bustling Chinese city of Harbin is only 400 miles from Khabarovsk. As Russia’s population declines, the Chinese population is only growing and many Chinese are looking to the Russian Far-East as a land of opportunity. There are already more than an estimated 30,000 Chinese illegally working and residing in the Khabarovsk region. Unless Russia can increase the population of Khabarovsk and create a viable immigration policy, many locals fear that the Chinese will eventually control the region’s economy.

There are approximately 11,000 Jews currently living in Khabarovsk. How did Jews get to the Russian Far East? To get an answer to this question, I had dinner with Dr. Victoria Romanova, a professor of history in Khabarovsk who specializes in the Jewish history of the region. Dr. Romanova explained that there were Jews in Khabarovsk as early as the founding of the city as a Russian city in 1858. Prior to that, control of the region switched between the Russians and Chinese. These were either ex-prisoners from Siberia or veteran soldiers who were allowed to live anywhere in the Russian empire they chose. The Jewish population and general population grew dramatically after the completion of the trans-Siberian railroad in 1903.

Much of our discussion focused on Birobijan. Birobijan is a region just south of Khabarovsk created by Stalin in 1931 as a Jewish Autonomous region. In 1931, Stalin created the Birobijan Jewish Autonomous Region as a Soviet alternative to Zionism. By creating a homeland for Jews within the Soviet Union, Stalin hoped to both rid the European parts of the country of Jews and increase the population of the Russian far – East. Many thousands of Jews traveled to Birobijan in the early 1930s. Even Jews from the United States and other countries traveled to Birobijan in that time to take part in building the new region.

By World War II, Birobijan had failed. Creating a paradise in Siberia was never really in the cards. Aside from being a frozen tundra most of the year, Birobijan is just too isolated geographically to attract many people. There is still a mall population of Jews remaining in Birobijan although most of the population has moved to Khabarovsk in the past decade.

I visited the synagogue of Khabarovsk which is a large newly opened building in the center of the city. Hillel keeps an activity room and office on the third floor. The synagogue was built on the site of the original Khabarovsk synagogue which was destroyed during the Soviet period and used as a theatre. The Rabbi works together with the Hillel and other organizations in a mutually beneficial and cooperative arrangement.

I met a group of Hillel students who explained how Hillel has given them an opportunity to live a Jewish life. Before Hillel, they were Jewish in name only but had no idea of what it meant to live a Jewish life. The students reminded me of students in America. They all have cell phones, surf the internet, and are trying to negotiate the difficult first steps of adulthood. They ask the same questions and have many of the same challenges as students anywhere in the world. I even met several students who were from Khabarovsk originally, had moved to Israel, and were now back. (There are an estimated 30,000 Russian speakers who have lmoved to Israel and returned to Russia in the last few years.)

The next morning, we accompanied a Hillel student named Anya to visit an elderly woman who receives material aid from the American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee. Sofia Isaacovna is 94 years old and has lived in Khabarovsk all of her life. Her parents came to Khabarovsk from a city near Lake Baikal in Siberia. She insisted that her family has always been from Siberia and had no recollection of knowing of any of her grandparents coming from Europe.

I asked Sofia if she remembered anything from before the 1917 Communist revolution. She smiled and said she thinks she does. She remembers that he parents spoke Yiddish and that they celebrated Pesach every year. She remembers the Matza. However, most of Sofia’s life was lived under the Soviet regime. Sofia was a party member and worked in the regional party headquarters all of her career. She said she had no Jewish life at all during that period. Sofia never married nor had children but she has a nephew and grandnephew in Khabarovsk who visit her regularly.

My second night in Khabarovsk featured a dinner with a group of Hillel Business Club representatives. The local Hillel has organized a group of young entrepreneurs who meet on a regular basis to network and celebrate Jewish holidays. The club also donates small amounts of money every month to the Jewish community. One member, Sergei, is a founder of a network of convenience stores throughout Khabarovsk. Sergei and the other members said that working and living Moscow or the West remain a dream and a long term goal.

I had the pleasure of spening most of my trip to Khabarovsk with the Hillel Director, Ilya and his twin brother Igor. The brothers eagerly told me that they had never been circumcised as babies and they were undergoing a full Jewish bris the following week. Although I winced at the thought, I was amazed at their commitment to being Jewish. While Americans in Israel or North America take being Jewish for granted these Jews still revel in their newfound freedom to live as Jews.

Throughout more than 70 years of Soviet rule, having a bris was illegal, gathering as Jews was dangerous and repression was the norm. Now, young Jews freely congregate and Hillel gives them an opportunity to explore Jewish life.These young Jews know the value of their freedom and take learning about Judaism very seriously. They recognize that they have a responsibility to build local Jewish communities and teach their parents and friends about Judaism.

From Khabarovsk, I flew back to Moscow where I spent a few days and then went on to Odessa in Ukraine. Odessa, on the Black Sea, was the home of a majority of the great Zionist thinkers and many of the great Jewish artistis and intellectuals. I wandered the old cobblestone streets and saw the homes of Jabotinsky, Ahad Ha'am, Dubnow, Pinsker, and others.

Only a few hours later, at the Odessa Hillel, I was treated to an impromptu concert by Hillel students who sang and played violin and guitar. For some inexplicable reason, Odessa is still an incubator for Jewish artists and intellectuals. While the Hillel budget in Odessa is only a few thousand dollars a year, the students are eager to both create a community and to explore Jewish life.

I landed in Israel last night and am spending shabbat with friends in Jerusalem. Arriving in Israel is always special and emotional for me. The sun is setting now and shabbat is beginning. The streets are empty except for people walking to synagogue. The overwhelming feeling is a simple one: I am home.

This has been an exciting and insightful trip. I always feel lucky to be able to make an impact on community development in the former Soviet Union. As long as Jews decide to stay there, we should help them in whatever way we can. As a global movement on almost every continent, Hillel has the opportunity to create a global Jewish community. In so doing, we have the ability to make an impact on the larger world around us.

Sorry for the length of this e-mail but this is already heavily edited.

Shabbat Shalom,

Avi

Sunday, October 02, 2005

Peace Corps Stories


It was April, 1994 and I would be graduating from college in one month. I woke up one morning to the sound of the ringing phone.

“Mr. Rubel?”

“Yes,” I answered.

“I’m calling from the United States Peace Corps. We would like to invite you to serve as a volunteer.”

“Oh my god. Really? Where?”

“Kyrgyzstan”

“Kurdistan? I didn’t think there was such a country.”

“No, Mr. Rubel. KyrGyzstan. It’s in the former Soviet Union, and it borders China. Look on a map.”

“When does it start?”

“You would leave on June 6th. That’s less than two months from now. You have ten days to decide.”

When I tell people that I lived in Kyrgyzstan for two years they usually get a sheepish look on their faces and admit that they are not sure where Kyrgyzstan is located. I tell them that it’s east of Berserkistan and west of Kabookistan. The conversation usually ends with people saying “yeah those ‘stans’. That is really the middle of nowhere, eh?”

To give you an idea of what the middle of nowhere is like, Kyrgyzstan’s capital, Bishkek, is named for the wooden spoon that the Kyrgyzs use to mix the fermented mare’s milk, yes, I said mare’s milk, that the Kyrgyzs love to drink in the summer. Unlike Uzbekistan, which has the distinction of being one of only two countries in the world that are doubly land-locked (you have to go through two other countries to reach a significant body of water-the other is Liechtenstein), Kyrgyzstan is easily in range of a beautiful coast-line – after going through 3,000 miles of China.

What attracted me to this bustling, cosmopolitan world capital? What was a nice Jewish boy doing in a place like Kyrgyzstan? While some people may not find it an appealing idea to spend two years in the middle of nowhere, I though it was a grand idea. This was Central Asia: the roof of the world, the Silk Road, and Genghis Khan. I didn’t feel crazy, just filled with wanderlust and a need for adventure. This was a place in the midst of a monumental transition from Soviet, communist rule to independence and free-market capitalism. The people are predominantly Muslim yet have been cut off from the larger Muslim world for a century. The lack of flush toilets notwithstanding, I couldn’t think of a more interesting place to spend two years.

I certainly don’t blame people for not being able to place Kyrgyzstan on a map. In fact, its obscurity is one of its greatest attributes. For me however, perhaps the most daunting thing about considering spending two years in Kyrgyzstan was that I wasn’t sure I could pronounce Kyrgyzstan correctly. Doesn’t it seem like there must be an extra letter in there by mistake? Is it even ethical to go to a country you can’t pronounce? I also had to take into account that my friends and family thought I was crazy for going to spend two years in a remote Central Asian former Soviet backwater. The more intrepid, like my 82 year old grandmother, thought it was a fine idea. Of course, I had to take her advice with a grain of salt because she also told me to try to come home with a nice Jewish girl.

Arrival

We landed in Alma-Ata, Kazakhstan on June 7, 1994. Kazakhstan is a country half the size of the continental United States yet has a population of only 10 million. From New York, we had flown approximately 9,000 miles to get there. The first thing I noticed when I disembarked from the airplane was the towering mountains. I stood at the top of the stairs leading down to the tarmac and stared at the mountain peaks in the distance. I had been to Colorado, but this was something entirely different. In every direction there were towering, mountains, with beautiful snow–capped peaks. They were so close and completely dominated the landscape.

The second thing I noticed were that the people who greeted us at the airport looked so Asian. They looked almost Chinese. They were holding a Peace Corps sign and smiling and waving at us. We immediately boarded a bus for the drive to Kyrgyzstan’s capital, Bishkek. On the bus, I had a chance to get acquainted with some of the other Peace Corps volunteers with whom I would be sharing this experience. We were a group of about 30, and I was definitely one of the youngest. The average age was probably 26 although there was a couple in their fifties and two older women in their sixties. Everyone seemed very friendly and excited to see this new world.

We pulled into Bishkek in the late afternoon and were greeted by the rest of the training staff. I was tired from the trip, and I don’t remember the first night so clearly. I do, however, remember wandering down the street with some other volunteers near the hotel we stayed at, looking for a place to get a beer. There were no streetlights and all we could see were groups of men wearing strange cone-shaped hats squatting in small groups in the street. This certainly was strange. They seemed to look at us suspiciously as we passed. After awhile, we gave up trying to find a restaurant or bar and went to sleep. As I dozed off, I thought about how exciting it was to be in such a foreign place. I realized that I had absolutely no idea what awaited me. I was leaving everything I knew and stepping off into the void.

The next day, after breakfast, we were brought to a balcony overlooking the lobby of the hotel. There were lots of people milling about in the lobby. Our training director explained to us that we were now going to be given host families where we would live for the next 3 months of training. We were to take our things with the family and spend the rest of the day with them. We were to meet back at the hotel the following morning.

I waited for my name to be called and looked down at the families waiting in the lobby. They were mostly Asians with some Russian looking families as well. They looked as nervous as I felt. I was going to live with them for 3 months? How was I supposed to do this?

When my name was called, I dragged my duffel bags down the stairs and met Anatoly. He was a tall, mustachioed, very Russian looking man. He shook my hand, and took one of my bags. As we walked outside I noticed he had a heavy limp. We loaded the bags into the back of a little Russian made car that could barely handle my stuff and drove what seemed like just around the corner to an apartment complex.

There were four massive gray concrete apartment houses. Each building looked exactly alike. To put it mildly, they were falling apart. It reminded me of pictures I had seen of Beirut in the 1980s. When Anatoly and I entered one of buildings dragging my bags, the first thing that hit me was the smell. It stank like something rotting. The next thing that struck me was how decrepit the building looked. The concrete was a grayish color and most of the walls were crumbling. The front hallway of the building was filled with graffiti. I immediately noticed a swastika. My stomach dropped. Oh my god.

Amazingly, there was a working elevator in the building. We rode it to the sixth floor and Anatoly ushered me into an apartment. A small woman with short, dyed-red hair, a warm smile, and mouth full of god teeth greeted me.

“I am Larissa,” she slowly said, enunciating each syllable.

“I am Avi,” I answered.

“This is my family. Family – yes?” she asked, gesticulating to the children around her.

“Yes, family,” I answered.

“This Yulia,” she said, pointing to a blushing teenager.

“This Nastia,” she said, pointing to a little girl who was hiding behind Anatoly.

“This Anatoly,” she said pointing to Anatoly.

“Yes,” I laughed. “I met Anatoly.”

“You America?” she asked.

“Yes, I am from America,” I replied.
Larissa began walking down the hallway. She motioned for me to follow. She opened a door to and pointed inside. “This you,” she said.

This was my room. Anatoly dragged my bags to the room. It was a child’s room with a bed, a desk, and a closet. I realized that this must be one of the kids’ rooms. Where would they be sleeping?

Larissa began showing me around the apartment. She had a high pitched laugh, and she seemed to think that either it was very funny that she couldn’t really speak to me or it was funny that I would be living with them. I thought it was funny too, but I wasn’t laughing. I was trying to be polite and thankful while trying to control the panic rising in my throat. I was going to live here for three months?

There were two other bedrooms which meant that the kids would be sleeping together in one room. There was also a kitchen and a living room. The worst part of the apartment was the animals. It turned out that Anatoly was actually a hunter and taxidermist. There were animals, mostly birds, at various stages of being stuffed, all over the place.

The table was set in the kitchen and Larissa invited me to sit. I didn’t know it yet, but this was the beginning of the “Make Avi fat” campaign the likes of which I had never seen before. We all sat around the table. Only Larissa could speak a little English. I spoke no Russian. Larissa and I began a conversation using words, gestures and a lot of additional body language. Slowly, by the time we reached the third course, Yulia had also tentatively joined in the conversation. Anatoly ate and then excused himself (I would never exchange more than 10 words with the man). Nastia just sat there staring at me.

The wonderful thing about speaking with someone with whom you do not share a common language is that so much is open to interpretation. I learned that Larissa is a cook or she might work in a factory. God knows what they understood from my wild pantomime when I tried to explain that I was from the East Coast. It was kind of fun.

The one thing I conclusively learned at our first meal together was that I was undoubtedly going to have diarrhea later. Three different forms of fried potatoes slathered in oil, a lot of meat, and other assorted unappetizing delicacies were all copiously forced on me by Larissa. Months later I learned a term that perfectly fits my situation at Larissa’s kitchen table: terrorist hospitality.

After the meal, Larissa showed me back to my room and motioned for me to unpack. I closed the door, sat down on the bed, and put my head in my hands. What had I gotten myself into? Where the hell was I? This was going to be really difficult. These people seemed to only speak Russian, yet the Peace Corps people said we were going to start learning Kyrgyzs the next day. I took several deep breaths. Three months was not such a long time. Then, I’d go to a permanent site for the rest of my service. I could do this. I knew that I would make it work, but I suddenly felt very alone. I missed everyone – my friends and family. This was not going to be easy.

Three Weeks Later
Training went well. My mornings were spent conjugating Russian verbs while trying to hold down Larissa’s breakfasts. Although Russian is supposed to be difficult, the breakfasts proved infinitely more challenging. I definitely consumed more oil at Larissa’s table than all the rest of my life up to that point. The scariest part of it is that the she poured the oil from a huge glass jug that she takes down to the street to get refilled. For all I know my breakfasts were fried in Quaker State.

In the first week of training everyone started learning Kyrgyzs. The funny thing is that nobody in Bishkek speaks Kyrgyzs. They all speak Russian. The government is slowly making Kyrgyzs the state language, and apparently, everyone speaks it in the villages. In the cosmopolitan centers, people may speak Kyrgyzs at home but almost everyone speaks Russian on the street. The Peace Corps was trying to be politically correct so they decided to teach everyone Kyrgyzs.

Larissa and Anatoly are Ukrainian and they do not speak Kyrgyzs. In fact, when I came home from training and told them the words I had learned in Kyrgyzs, they indicated to me how funny it was that I would learn Kyrgyzs when they considered it a barbaric language that only the provincial Kyrgyzs speak.

In the second week, the Peace Corps reconsidered and made a Russian class for those of us with Slavic host families. So, I’ve been learning Russian for 8 hours a day for the past two weeks. I can finally ask for some things at Larissa’s table and thank her for her hospitality. That feels good.

A funny thing happened the other day when I came home after training. They gave me a spare key so I can come and go as I pleased. It was around 6 pm when I unlocked the door and entered apartment. A noise in the kitchen got my attention, and when I looked inside I was confronted with Larissa, wearing a gray leotard, strapped to the kitchen table with some kind of wide belt around her waist. Her face was beet red, and she just pointed to the table and shrugged her shoulders. The only time I had ever seen a belt like that was in an old I Love Lucy episode where Lucy’s friend Ethel is exercising with a similar contraption.

I contemplated bolting out of the room, but I realized that Larissa was stuck. I moved closer to the table and understood her predicament. The belt, which was plugged into the wall behind her, was fastened to the table with a vice like device. She couldn’t loosen the vice. I suppose that when turned on, the belt shakes and somehow helps in weight loss. The next part would be very tricky. Dislodging Larissa from the table would require me getting under the table and very close to her. I knew she was my host “mother,” but I hadn’t anticipated us getting this close.

I crawled under the table and freed Larissa from the table. She quickly unplugged and folded up the belt contraption and scurried out of the room to change. I anticipated a new awkwardness between us but was pleasantly surprised by how this incident seemed to loosen up our relationship. Not that she began only wearing leotards around me, but for some reason we began communicating better. In fact, I think I became Larissa’s confidant.

Bishkek was originally called Pishkek and then the Soviets renamed it Frunze after Michael Frunze, the soldier who helped bring Central Asia under Soviet control (i.e. in the name of freedom he invaded a sovereign people and subjected them to 70 years of authoritarian rule). Anyway, after independence, in 1992, Pishpek was renamed Bishkek. Thank god they changed it; to me Pishkek could be nothing other than a brand of adult diapers.

Bishkek is, in many ways, a typical Soviet built city of approximately 1 million people. The city consists of impossibly large apartment blocks, all equally ugly and rundown, mixed with austere government buildings. There is a “white house” where the President, Askar Akaev’s headquarters are, located in the central square where a huge statue of Lenin still stands. Lenin has one arm outstretched, showing the masses the way toward the glorious future.

Although many Soviet icons were torn down following the collapse of the Union, the massive Lenin in Bishkek’s main square still stands. It is at once a reminder of Kyrgyzstan’s Soviet past and a testament to how pervasive the cult of Lenin was in this culture – more than 4,000 miles from Moscow. More than ten years after the fall of Communism and most people in Kyrgyzstan still cite Lenin as their number one role model.

I lived with Larissa and Anatoly for my three months of training. My Russian progressed and I was able to carry on simple conversations. Toward the end of the training I was informed that I was being placed in a village called Aravan in the south of the country. All I knew was that Aravan was in the Ferghana Valley, was mostly populated by Uzbeks, and was an agricultural region specializing in cotton and tobacco.

I thought that my first three months in Bishkek were an adventure, but I had yet to realize how intense and life-changing the next two years would be.

Aravan
It’s at least 100 degrees and I have severe diarrhea. When you drink something in Kyrgyzstan, you never know what it’s going to do to you. I’m sitting in a jeep with a man and two women. I just got off a plane that flew over the Tien Shan Mountains to the south of Kyrgyzstan. We landed close to the main city, Osh, and these people picked me up at the airport. They were taking me to my new home. All three of them are shorter than me, and I’m only 5’5”. They are dark skinned with high cheek bones, very Asian looking. He is wearing a grey suit and hat that look like 1950s fashion. The two women are wearing dresses that also look like they were popular in the 1950s. They greet me very warmly and seem eager to welcome me.

I speak enough Russian at this point to greet them, and I understand a drop of what they are saying. The older woman, Aizada, is the director of the school where I will teach. The younger woman, Jamila, is an English teacher at the school. She speaks passable English, but seems very embarrassed. The man, Kurmanbek, is very serious. I don’t know what his role is. I am dying to use a bathroom. I am also very excited and nervous to be going to the town where I will spend the next two years.

We are driving in very brown, hilly country. It is late August and the Fall crops are just being planted. Granite mountains frame the landscape in the distance. The people I see on the side of the road look very different from the people in northern Kyrgyzstan. They looked more Middle Eastern. These were Uzbeks.

Soon, the houses appear more frequently and we enter a town. Aizada, Jamila and Kurmanbek announce that we are in Aravan, my new home. The roads are mostly dirt. We cross over a small river, and pull into a dirt yard in front of a few two-story apartment buildings. There are dirty, shirtless kids playing in the yard. The buildings are crude concrete structures, but they are the only thing resembling apartments that I see in the town. I guess this will be home.

Everyone helps unload my bags and brings them to the second floor of one building. A crowd of people gathers in the yard to watch. We enter the apartment, and I am given a brief tour of my new home. It is a spacious place, but reminds me more of a KOA campground than an apartment. There is a kitchen, living room, bedroom, and balcony. They tell me that I have fifteen minutes to wash up, and then we would have lunch. They leave.

I find the bathroom and realize very quickly that although there is a sink, there is no running water. I go to the bedroom, sit down on the bed, and put my face in my hands. Where the hell am I? What have I gotten myself into? Kurmanbek appears at the front door a moment later and with a big smile presents me with a bucket of water.

When I exit the apartment a few minutes later, a crowd of children is waiting for me. As I walk past smiling, one brave boy screams “Hello” and the rest of the children imitate him screaming “Hello” and giggling. They are a mixture of Uzbek, Russian, and Kyrgyzs kids. I am the first American any of them have ever seen. I say “Hello” and shake each of their hands.

Kurmanbek, Jamila and Aizada walk me across the yard to Kurmanbek’s apartment. Inside, I meet Kurmanbek’s wife, Mairam, and their three children, Damir, Jildiz and Almaz. I am ushered into a room where cushions are laid out around the perimeter and a large multi-colored tablecloth covers the center. Slices of melons, grapes, nuts, and candies cover the tablecloth. I am motioned to sit in the center of one of the cushions.

A few moments later other men come into the room. I am introduced to the Hakim, or mayor of the town and several other men who all sit down on the cushions. None of the women except for Jamila joins us. She is to be my interpreter. Everyone begins sipping black tea from ceramic saucers that are continually refilled. I do not want to eat. I am already sick, but I do not want to be impolite.

Everyone beams at me, shakes my hand, and slaps me on the back. I am a celebrity here. They are all eager to talk to me, and I try my Russian. They all say it is very good, but I know they are just humoring me.

Mairam first brings in soup. It is an oily broth with potatoes, vegetables and meat. Everyone gets his own bowl. As I eat, I am aware of all of them carefully watching me eat. I try some of the soup and attempt to leave some in the bowl. No such luck. I am being judged here and the hand motions and facial expressions indicate that they all want me to finish my soup. Oh god – this isn’t going to be pretty. I am excited to meet these people, but I really need some time to myself.

Next she serves tomato salad with onions and pieces of sheep meat. Everyone eats from the same communal plates that are passed around. I am stuffed. I thought Larissa’s training had prepared me for anything, but I was about to experience a whole new level of terrorist hospitality.

When the bottle of vodka appears, I groan internally and smile for my hosts. There are several toasts made in honor of my arrival. I make a toast, and tell them I am happy to be here with my new friends in my new home. I am thinking of escape at this point. I am hoping that the drinking was the final stage, and I would be allowed to leave soon.

Just then, an enormous plate of Palow, the Uzbek national dish, is presented. Palow is a cousin to what we, in the West, know as Pilaf. It consists of rice, carrots, onions and generous portions of sheep, all cooked in viscous cottonseed oil. Palow is served in a mound on one plate placed in the center of the floor. Everyone begins eating with their cupped right hands, but they give me a spoon. I place it on the side and begin copying them and eating with my hand. They crack up laughing and my back is slapped again and again. Apparently, I am now one of the boys. They push more and more of the Palow in front of me.

They are all very friendly and have many questions for me. They ask about my family and where I am from. With toasts of vodka, they tell me that Aravan is a good place and that the people here will be friendly to me. I make a toast to them in English about Aravan and their hospitality. They smile, clap their hands, and seem happy with my performance.

The shots of vodka and all of this food are wrecking me, and I tell Jamila that I am very tired. At first they protest, but they let me off easy on my first day. I am excused. I tell Jamila I will rest, unpack and meet them again in the morning.

Jamila and Kurmanbek escort me back to my apartment. I say thank you over and over again until the door is closed. Then, I make a mad dash for the toilet. Unfortunately, I remain there for most of the evening. This place is going to take some getting used to. That evening, I emerge from my apartment with an empty bucket looking for water. Several children appear and lead me to the water pipe at the far end of the yard. They tell me their names and we begin a conversation in Russian. They seem both thrilled to be talking to me but are afraid to come too close. I am like ET to these kids.

A few hours later, I lie in the strange bed unable to sleep. Although I am feeling better, I am scared to be living in this strange place. Two years seems like such a long time. Could I actually live here for two years? Would I make it? I think about the girlfriend I had left to come here. What was I thinking? I feel alone. ET phone home?

The next morning, feeling refreshed, I spend some time unpacking. I wash my face from water out of the bucket, and then came out in the yard to look around Aravan. The kids from the night before are playing in the yard and they come over to talk to me. They all knew how to say “Hello, my name is ____,” but not much else. I meet all of the kids and sit in the yard teaching them English words. I feel better after a night’s sleep.

Jamolidin
I feel a tap on my shoulder and turn around coming face to face with a middle aged man in a grey pin striped suit wearing a black, square hat with paisley-like symbols on all four sides. This was an Uzbek Dopu worn by most Uzbek men. I immediately notice the Peace Corps pin on his lapel. He is dark skinned with high cheekbones, and a handsome but somewhat weathered face. He reaches out a hand and said, “Hello Mr. Avi Rubel. I am Jamolidin Hajimatov, the leader of the English teachers of Aravan for twenty years.”

“Hello,” I say. He had completely surprised me, and I was happy at his apparent facility with English. “It’s nice to meet you.”
“We have been waiting for you for a long time. How is Mr. Martin Shapiro?” Martin Shapiro was the Peace Corps Assistant Director who had visited Aravan to arrange for my arrival.

“He is fine,” I answer. “How do you know him?”

“Mr. Martin Shapiro is my friend. He has come here to visit with us. He is a very kind man. Now, let us go. My family is waiting for you. We will succeed.” He speaks in short, authoritative sentences as if he is used to giving orders.

I understood whence the Peace Corps pin. ‘Uh, ok,” I say, “I think Jamila and Kurmanbek will be looking for me.”

“No,” he said, cutting me off. “They know you will be with me. We will succeed.”

His English is very good, and he seems official, so I follow him out of the yard and to the dirt road. He walks stiffly upright with his hands clasped behind his back. As we walk down the road, people stare at me and greet Jamolidin with a hand across their belly, an Uzbek sign of respect, saying “Asalam Aleikum, Domla.” Domla is a word that is offered to elders or respected teachers. He seems to know everyone.

At the first intersection, we turn left onto a paved road and enter downtown Aravan. Perhaps downtown is not the best word since it consisted of a bus station and small bazaar, or market. The street is crowded with Uzbek men and women and almost everyone greets Jamolidin and stares at me.

Jamolidin leads me into the bazaar which consists of rows of countertops laden with fruits and vegetables. There are also stalls with candies and men with wheelbarrows piled with round, flat loaves of bread. I feel the eyes of everyone on me as Jamolidin leads me through the large rectangular-shaped building. In one corner, there is a butcher’s section flies swarming everywhere, and slabs of meat hanging on hooks. We walk out the back of the building and into an alley filled on both sides with row after row of yellow, rugby-ball shaped melons stacked five feet high. There are at least ten different men selling the melons and they are boisterously competing with one another. Jamolidin buys two from one man who points at me and asks Jamolidin about me. Jamolidin explains who I am, and introduces me to the man as Mr. Avi. The man seems to have heard of me before. I feel like a movie star.

We walk past the melons and crossed over a narrow river on a rickety wooden bridge. Jamolidin motions to the river and says, “This is Aravan’s river, the Aravan-Sai.” We continue up a dirt road.
“How many people live in Aravan?” I ask Jamolidin.
“It is a village,” he answers. “We live in the center, but there are many more people in the Aravan region.”

I later learned that there are approximately 10,000 people in the center of the region and a total of 40,000 in the region. “Where do you learn all of your English?” I ask him, “It is very good.”

“It is not very good, thank you,” he answered. “I studied in the university in Osh many years ago. I have always been an English teacher.”

“Have you ever been to America or England?” I ask him. His accent is very slight.

“No,” he answers. I have never left the Soviet Union. Mr. Martin Shapiro was the first American I ever met. You are the second.”

It seems amazing that his English could be so good and his accent so light yet he had never spoken with a native speaker. I was impressed.

The houses on the sides of the road are very close to each other. They are all one story homes and many have second floor storage barns with tobacco leaves drying in the sun. Jamolidin stops, opens one large wooden door, and motions me inside a courtyard. “This will be your home,” he says. I’m not sure what he means.

The courtyard is gorgeous. From the outside it is difficult to get a sense of an Uzbek home. The home is shaped like a horseshoe with the open end facing away from the street. Jamolidin’s courtyard contains a large tea-bed with a small table and cushions on it. The tea-bed sits underneath a beautiful grape arbor with large clusters of grapes hanging down for the taking. A cooking area is on one side of the yard and a pot is boiling on a wood stove. In the back of the courtyard, close to the open side, are Jamolidin’s livestock: a cow and a few sheep. Several rooms open off the sides of the courtyard.

As Jamolidin shows me around, with a look of pride, a woman and a young boy enter into the courtyard.

“This is my wife,” he says. “She will be your mother.” She is a homely woman, shoulders stooped, practically hidden underneath her headscarf.

“And this is my youngest son, Nuridin,” Jamolidin continues. The cute young boy of 9 or 10 shakes my hand vigorously and says, “Hello. My name is Nuridin.”
“He is lazy,” Jamolidin continues. “I want him to learn English.”

Not understanding, Nuridin continues to beam at me.“Good,” I say. “I will help him.”

Jamolidin motions me to the tea-bed. “Sit down,” he said, “Your mother has prepared some food.”

I sit on the tea-bed and complement Jamolidin on his home. When I point to the grapes, he jumps up on the tea-bed, unsheathes a knife that is fastened to his belt, and cuts off a cluster. He then sits down, takes off his dopu, and smoothes out his thinned, graying hair.

Jamolidin’s wife first presents us with freshly baked bread and hot tea. Jamolidin motions for her to wash the grapes. From their interaction, I understand that she will not be joining us at the table. Jamolidin appears to be very much the king of his house.

“How many children do you have? I ask.

“Four,” he replies.

“Do they all live in Aravan?”

“No. One son is in Turkmenistan. Another one is in Osh.”

“They are all boys?”

“I have four boys and two girls.”

I nod, understanding that boys and girls are counted very differently in this society. “Tell me about your work.”

I am the leader of the English teachers of Aravan,” he repeats proudly. “I teach at an Uzbek language school. You will be teaching at the Russian school. I hope you will come to my school as well.”

I assure him that I will.

“The English teachers in Aravan are very bad,” he continues. “They do not speak English. Most of them did not attend university. They received their degrees from a correspondence course. You will see.”

Jamolidin’s wife returns to the table with steaming bowls of soup, similar to what I was served the night before at Kurmanbek’s house. We eat the soup, and I tell Jamolidin about my family. He asks me how many rooms we have in our house. I am embarrassed to tell him that my parent’s house has four bedrooms. I tell him that everything in America is large and that we are not very rich. He nods in understanding, but I know that I could never explain my life in America to him.

By the time we finish the soup I am stuffed, but I should have realized that Palow would be served. I add to my mental checklist that I will have to learn how to either refuse food or find ways to eat less. Jamolidin invites Nuridin to the table and we sit and eat the steaming rice and meat. I insist on eating it with my hands, Uzbek style.

“Mr. Avi,” Jamolidin asks,” Do you think you will live here with my family?”
I thought he was being hospitable by calling his wife my mother and his home my home, but I realize he is serious.

“Well,” I stammer, “Kurmanbek and Aizada told me I would live in my apartment. I think I have to live here.”

“We will succeed.” He replies. “This will be your home.”

I don’t know what to say. He is very hospitable, but I would like to have my own apartment.
.
“Can I use your bathroom?” I ask.

Jamolidin points to an outhouse in one corner of the yard. I enter the outhouse and squat over the putrid hole. There is no toilet paper. Instead, there is an old book with pages already missing that I am supposed to use. This is going to take a lot of getting used to.

When I return, Jamolidin motions me into one of the room of his house. “Now, we will rest,” he says. He lies down on a few cushions and motions for me to do the same. “After we rest we will go to your apartment and bring your things here.”

I lie on the cushions unsure of how to handle this situation. I don’t want to be rude and I don’t understand if the apartment is really mine and if I am expected to live with Jamolidin. I look across the room and see that Jamolidin is sleeping. I close my eyes, hoping I will be able to keep my apartment.

“Mr. Avi,” Jamolidin says, “You must wake up.”

I shake my head realizing where I am. I must have dozed off. I sit up and see that Jamolidin has changed his clothes. I walk into the yard with Jamolidin and he tells me to say goodbye to Nuridin and my mother.

I thank both of them and we head out of Jamolidin’s house and begin walking toward my apartment. We walk on dirt roads and again, people greet Jamolidin and stare at me.

“Everyone is excited that you are here,” Jamolidin tells me. “They want to meet you and to have you as a guest. I will make sure you are safe.”

I begin to sense that Jamolidin likes being in the limelight. It seems like he wants to be my agent. As we approach my apartment I thank Jamolidin for his hospitality. I tell him I look forward to coming to his home again soon. I add that I will stay in my apartment because the Peace Corps told me I should be living alone.

Jamolidin looks at me and furrows his brow. “You will live here now and then you will come to me,” he says. With several onlookers staring at us, he hugs me.
“We will succeed,” he says and heads back down the dirt road toward his house.
Baba Masha

In my first few months living in Aravan, everyone wanted to have the American as a guest and so I was plied on a daily basis with obscene amounts of sheep, cotton seed oil, and rice. You don’t realize what a blessing it is to be regular until you’re running frantically through the streets of a Central Asian village looking for the closest outhouse.

I began to look for ways to supplement my diet and to find ingredients that I could use to cook more familiar food. One thing that was missing from my diet was eggs. I hadn’t seen one egg since I arrived. But there were plenty of scrawny chickens clucking in the streets and yards. Where were the eggs? I began asking my neighbors where I might be able to procure some eggs. I received widely different answers none of which brought me any closer to an omelet. One neighbor told me to try the bazaar. No luck. Another neighbor told me I would have to go into the closest city, Osh. I couldn’t believe that there were no eggs in Aravan. Were they keeping the eggs from me on purpose? Was this an anti-American conspiracy?

Of all resources lacking in the former Soviet Union, the most precious and most difficult to obtain is information. Information is power and the Soviet State hoarded it all and taught people to exist on a diet of carefully crafted bits and pieces. The failure of the Soviet Union is intimately tied to the inability of a centralized state to allow for a flow of information throughout society. This limits innovation. In the Soviet system every citizen was taught to do their little part and not to think on a larger scale. It could be dangerous to have new ideas. The eggs were no exception. Nobody would tell me where to find eggs.

As a Peace Corps volunteer with plenty of time on my hands, a desire to explore my new home, and a hankering for familiar tastes, I became determined to discover the hidden eggs of Aravan. I asked everyone in my neighborhood and school. Finally, one neighbor cracked. I don’t know if it was because I kept pestering her about eggs or if she let the information slip inadvertently. Anyway, weeks into my egg-quest, a neighbor named Zoya told me that an old Russian lady down the road sold eggs. Her name was Baba Masha. I asked Zoya which house she lived in but she just shrugged her shoulders and went back into her house.

The next afternoon I headed down the road in search of Baba Masha. I walked along the river and passed several of my students who stopped their playing to say hello to me. We had a typical conversation that I had with my students when I saw them outside of school:

“Hello Mr. Avi,” they sang out.
“Hello Dilfuza. Hello Dilnoza. Hello Alisher.”
“How are you?” they asked together in sing-song voices.
“I am fine thank you. How are you?”
“I am fine too,” they all answered in unison.
I waved, they giggled, and I moved on.

It was a sunny day and it felt nice to be walking along the river with the craggy, brown mountains in clear view. After fifteen minutes of walking, I came across an old Russian lady on the side of the road, wearing a white house coat, cleaning a dish with the river water that flows through the gutter. I asked her if she knew where Baba Masha lived. She stood up, and I was amazed that she was so stooped that even standing up she was almost bent in half. She looked up at me with friendly blue eyes. Her face was weathered with deep creases and wrinkles and her long gray hair was tied in a bun on the back of her head. Her eyes were a surprisingly sparkling blue and one corner of her mouth turned upward in an involuntary smile as she regarded me.

“I am Baba Masha,” she said.

“Zoya, my neighbor, told me that you might sell me some eggs.” I inquired.

Baba Masha narrowed her eyes and examined me a little closer.

“Zoya told you,” she said. “OK, follow me.”

Eureka. I followed Baba Masha across the road and through a blue gate into a yard. She looked back at me over her shoulder and asked me who I was.

“My name is Avi,” I answered. “I am from America. I live near Zoya.”

“America?” she asked in a sarcastic tone. “Really, where are you from?”

“I really am from America,” I answered.

“Humph. Why would an American be in this place,” she stated clearly. Wait here for a minute.”

Baba Masha walked into the house and I could hear the raspy breathing of another person inside. In the yard were three fruit trees, a table and chairs, and a shed in one corner. Baba Masha came out of the house and approached me.

“I heard there was an American in Aravan,” she said. “We have a hard life here. Everything is terrible since Perestroika. I don’t understand. . . “

I wasn’t sure how to reply so I nodded my head in understanding. Baba Masha put her hand on my shoulder and said, “Come sinichka (little son), I will give you some eggs.”

We walked to one of the sheds and Baba Masha opened the door. It was a mini-chicken house. She removed four eggs from a shelf and handed them to me.

“How much?” I asked.

“No money,” she replied. “You take them. Go home.”

“No, Baba Masha,” I answered. “I insist on paying.”

“No, sinichka, you are a guest.”

“Well,” I answered, “I will come back to help you in your house.”

Baba Masha laughed and her blue eyes twinkled.

“Come back whenever you want,” she said.

I took the eggs and headed home excited about the prospect of deviling, hard-boiling, or frying. It doesn’t take much to make the day of a deprived Peace Corps volunteer. Baba Masha seemed like such a nice woman. She also seemed to want to talk more with me. There were such few Russians left in Aravan. Most had left after the fall of the Soviet Union. When did she come to this place? What was her life like? I knew I would see her again.

One day after school the next week I walked to Baba Masha’s. I knocked on the blue gate and there was no reply. I waited for a minute until I pushed the door open.

“Baba Masha,” I called out.

No answer. I walked into the yard and up to the door of the house. I could see Baba Masha in the kitchen through the window.

“Baba Masha,” I called out again.

This time she heard me and shuffled to the door. I was struck again by how stooped she was.

“Hello?” she said, opening the door. She screwed up her eyes and looked at me for a few seconds before she recognized me.

“Ahhhh, the American. I spoke with Zoya. She says you really are an American.”

“Yes,” I said, chuckling. “I am.”

“You want eggs?” she asked.

“Well, I answered. I told you I would come back to help you in your house.”

She flicked her hand at me. “What help? What can you do?”
“Well,” I answered, “I was thinking I could clear away the grass and weeds under your trees and help you plant a garden.”

Baba Masha looked at me a little closer and then smiled. She was missing a few teeth, had a few gold teeth and the rest were yellowed. “Well,” she said, “if you want to help a little, my Sasha will be thankful. His asthma doesn’t let him work anymore.”

Baba Masha pulled my arm and led me into the house. Inside, was a small room with a stove, a refrigerator, a television and a cot. An old man lay on the cot watching tv. I remembered the raspy breath from my last visit and saw that his thin chest rose up and down with each breath and he seemed to be fighting to try to inhale enough oxygen.

“This is my Sasha,” Baba Masha said.

“Hello,” I said to Sasha, reaching out my hand.

Sasha reached out a thin, wrinkled, soft hand. “Hello,” he said putting his hand in mine without looking away from the tv.

“Sasha, this is the American,” Baba Masha said.

“American? What American?” Sasha said.

“I told you,” Baba Masha said, “the American who is living here, teaching at the Russian school.”

Sasha’s head did not move from his pillow, but he looked up at me from the cot and his grey eyes met mine. He inspected me for a moment, grunted, and returned his attention to his tv. I stood there for a second, unsure if I should try to speak to him, when Baba Masha pulled my arm again and led me back outside.

“My Sasha has terrible asthma,” she said. “His medicine is very expensive, and we can’t get enough of it. He almost never leaves the house anymore. He just lies there.”

Baba Masha’s yard needed work, but the house was tidy and she seemed able to take care of herself and Sasha. I asked her if she had children.

“We have two children,” she answered. “They are both with their families in Russia. They never come here anymore. It is better in Russia.”

“How do you pay for Sasha’s medicine,” I asked.

“We both get a pension,” she said with a chuckle, “But we only get 100 som a month. With our new capitalism, we get nothing. We used to get everything almost for free!” she exclaimed. “Milk was five kopeks and bread was five kopeks. Now, we can’t buy anything.”

I imagined my grandparents living on ten dollars a month and grimaced. I knew I would never take free eggs from Baba Masha again. Baba Masha led me to the chicken shed. She handed me four eggs and told me to come back again anytime I wanted.

I gave Baba Masha one som for each egg and assured her that I would return on Sunday to help in the yard. Baba Masha fixed me with her glinting eyes and smiled.

“Good sinichka,” she said. “I will wait for you.”

Tuesday, August 09, 2005

Lessons From Shfar’Am: Looking Toward a New Israel

Lessons From Shfar’Am: Looking Toward a New Israel

Jerusalem, Israel
August 9, 2005

Last Thursday, 19 year old Israeli Eden Natan-Zada boarded bus number 165 at the central station in Haifa, Israel’s third largest city. He wore an Israeli army uniform and carried an Israeli Army issued M-16. The young man probably started his day in his adopted home in the Israeli settlement of Tapuah in the west bank. The bus headed toward the Israeli Arab town of Shfar’Am in the Western Galilee.

As the bus entered Shfar’Am, Natan-Zada lifted his gun and began to shoot. Four were killed including the bus driver. At least 20 others were seriously wounded as the bullets shattered many of the windows and shards of glass flew everywhere. By the time the shooting ended a crowd began to gather at the bus. Within a short amount of time, the crowd stormed the bus and beat Natan-Zada to death.

Sh’far Am is located in Israel proper. That is, it is not on land captured by Israel in the 1967, six day war, and is not part of what is formally considered Occupied Territory by mainstream Israelis and Pealestinians. Shfar’Am is an ancient Gallilean city. It is mentioned in the Talmud and was even the seat of the SanHedrin (The Jewish high court) in the second century. Today, there are approximately 27,000 Arab inhabitants of Shfar’Am, and the population is a co-existing mosaic of Christians, Muslims, and Druze.

Eden Natan-Zada had been AWOL from the Israeli army for at least one month. Army representatives had looked for him at his parents’ home but, apparently did not consider him enough of a risk to make his capture a priority. This is only one of many questions that need answering. It is not at all clear why the IDF did not make more of an effort to at least recover the IDF issued M-16 in Natan-Zada’s possession. It is also unclear if the lynch could have been prevented?

While Natan-Zada was obviously deranged and the IDF should initiate a series of investigations so as to minimize the possibility of this recurring, the real question about this terrible incident is how this kind of extremist activity is allowed to exist in Israeli society?

Natan-Zada lived in the extreme right-wing settlement of Tapuah for approximately two years. Tapuah, Hebrew for “apple,” is a notorious haven for ultra right-wing Jewish settlers. Among the people who live there are members of the outlawed Kahane Chai party. Kahane Chai was outlawed as a terrorist group by the Israeli government in 1994. Natan-Zada was a troubled Israeli youth who began to find meaning in the hateful words of settlers from Tapuah that he read on the internet in chat rooms. They essentially recruited him to come to live in Tapuah and prepared him to carry out this attack. Sound familiar? To me it sounds an awful lot like the suicide bombers in London last month who went to Pakistan to receive training.

This is the time to call a spade a spade. There is a paradox that has been at play in Israeli society for years. The paradox lies in the fact that although the majority of Israelis have long viewed land for peace as an acceptable and viable exchange with the Palestinians, this same majority has delayed and complicated such an exchange by fostering the development of the settlements.

For decades, Israeli Prime Ministers and the IDF have built up their position in eventual negotiations with the Palestinians by creating Jewish facts on the ground in the form of building settlement after settlement in the West Bank and Gaza. While some Israelis moved to the settlements to cash in on government offered economic incentives, these settlements also became a safe haven for extremist Jews. Instead of rooting them out and marginalizing them, Israeli society actually lauded them as pioneers and as the frontlines of Israel’s defense.

The right-wing extremist Israeli settlers were legitimized because they were the only ones willing to leave the coastal cities of Israel for the rough and tumble Occupied Territories where they became a de facto buffer between the Palestinians and the majority of Israel. All Israelis, including myself, want to protect the security of Israel and ensure the state’s eternal existence, but we have to take a hard internal look and do a lot of work in order to fulfill the promise of being a “light unto the nations.” Of course, the Palestinians have a lot of work to do as well if they are to be capable of building their own, peaceful state.

If we can learn anything from Eden Natan-Zada’s reprehensible actions it is that our own brand of extremists are no less terrorists than the Hamas suicide bombers. They believe in an ideology or theology that entitles them to take innocent life. But all of Israel shares the collective guilt for Natan-Zada’s actions. We let these people exist. We let them settle, expand, and teach hatred. The upcoming disengagement from Gaza is just the beginning of Israel’s coming to terms with the unfortunate expansionist mistakes of the past. Yes, the extremists on both sides of the conflict must be eliminated, but ultimately, all of Israeli society will have to bite its collective lip and accept blame for letting our own extremists exist in the first place.

Friday, July 29, 2005

Disengagement from Gaza: A Choice for Life

July 28, 2005

Disengagement from Gaza: A Choice for Life

Jerusalem, Israel

With two weeks until Israel’s planned disengagement from Gaza, there is a palpable sense of tension felt throughout the country. On everyone’s minds are the possible obstacles and things that could go wrong to delay or cancel the disengagement. Some Israelis are praying for these obstacles to come to pass, but a majority is hoping that the disengagement from Gaza is just the first step toward a final peace settlement with the Palestinians. To reach such a settlement, the Palestinians still must demonstrate a lot of progress in their ability to competently run their own affairs. However, it is the internal divisions within Israel that will prove decisive in shaping the relationships Israel builds with its neighbors in the coming years.

Israel is a very young country. At 57 years old, the identity of the state is still taking shape. In its formative years, most of Israel’s identity has been defined in reaction to existential threats. There have always been, and continue to be, enemies intent on destroying Israel. At least five major wars have been fought to preserve Israel’s existence. At the same time, signed peace treaties with Egypt and Jordan have been successful at ending major components of the conflict.

While the Oslo peace process ultimately failed, the picture of a possible final settlement with the Palestinians has been painted and is widely seen in Israel as the probable eventual outcome. With the death of Arafat and the disengagement from Gaza, the question is not if there will be a settlement, but when conditions will be ripe to move forward. Israel must always be vigilant in ensuring security for its citizens, but it looks more and more likely that political solutions will eventually bring an end to most of the armed conflict.

The streets of downtown Jerusalem are almost full with tourists this summer, and business owners here that were begging for customers a few short years ago are beginning to feel a sense of relief. In the Old City of Jerusalem, Palestinian merchants are finally seeing a flow of tourists after several years of almost absolute silence. Are tourists coming back to visit Israel because other terrorist attacks around the world have made Israel seem unexceptional as a dangerous place? I don’t think so. Tourists are returning to Israel because there is relative quiet here and a sense of progress towards peace.

But, the most important question facing Israelis right now is what will be the legacy of this generation for the future of the Jewish state? Since the end of the Six Day War of 1967, a majority of secular, mainstream Israelis have been guilty of providing tacit acceptance of the settler movement and the idea of a “Greater Israel.” Even though most Israelis did not move their families to the Gaza Strip or to hilltop settlements in the West Bank, they also did not prevent those who did move from doing so. A small yet zealous and determined percentage of Israel’s population comprised of the very right wing and extreme religious parties have succeeded in co-opting an inordinate amount of power at the expense of the values held by the liberal, western oriented majority.

Why did this happen? The extremist element in Israel has traditionally had so much power in Israel because the issue they care about, the right of Jews to settle the Land of Israel regardless of the price that others have to pay, was considered sacrosanct and taboo to challenge. No leader until Yitzchak Rabin dared formulate a position counter to the status quo, knowing that doing so would be political suicide. Yet in the 1990s, the time was ripe for a sea-change and Rabin rose to the challenge. After him, Ehud Barak continued to break taboos when he negotiated with the Palestinians over a settlement involving Jerusalem. Even the ultimate Israeli hawk, Ariel Sharon recognized that living in a constant state of war is unsustainable. If only for selfish reasons, he seems to have accepted the fact that somehow, Israel must be proactive in ending the conflict.

Those against the disengagement from Gaza are getting desperate. Yesterday, a group of Rabbis issued a “Pulsa Denura,” or a death decree for Prime Minister Ariel Sharon. These Rabbis, and they are not alone in the ultra-orthodox community, claim that Sharon’s decision to disengage from Gaza is tantamount to heresy and treason against the Jewish people. As everyone in Israel is aware, such a decree was issued by a Rabbi prior to Yitzhak Rabin’s murder in 1995 and was seen by his assassin as a “green light” to act. Security will be extra tight around the Prime Minister for at least the next few weeks.

At this crucial time in its development, Israel is faced with a set of choices that will determine the character of the state for at least the foreseeable future and probably a lot longer. Will Israel be an inward looking state that bends to the will of a minority that believes it has a monopoly on truth and that Jews have a special, God-given right to settle all of Biblical Israel regardless of the consequences? Or, will Israel reject this notion and cease lending any credence to the elements in its society that do not accept basic 21st century notions of Human Rights?

The settler movement’s most popular slogan lately has been: “Jews Don’t Exile other Jews.” The liberal Peace Now movement’s signs read: “Choose Life, Choose the Disengagement.” Strong leadership will be the decisive factor in swaying Israeli popular opinion. Perhaps Sharon, with his hardliner past, is the only leader who can actually convince enough people that now is the time to focus on a potentially bright future, to choose life, and to relegate all extremists to the margins of society where they belong.

Free Counters
Web Site Counter